Virginia "Free-Riding" Stock Schemer Sentenced for Multi-Million Dollar Fraud

The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Ohio announced last week the sentencing of Vriginia resident Sean M. Daly to 41 months imprisonment after Daly pled guilty to one count of securities fraud. The government alleged that, from 2001 through 2007, Daly engaged in a "free-riding" scheme to purchase stocks. "Free-riding" occurs where a purchaser of stocks places an order for stocks but has insufficient funds to cover the purchase price and instead uses the proceeds from the sale of the stock to cover the purchase. Free-riding schemes attempt to profit from short term changes in prices.

Daly ordered millions worth of securities through the accounts, using the names of nonexistent clients or corporations. He would monitor the price of the stocks during a three-day waiting period, and would refuse delivery of any stocks which had decreased in value, falsely claiming that he was waiting on an overseas client to make payment. Daly also issued false press releases and financial analyses to promote certain stocks which he had placed orders for in order to artificially increase their prices.

The scheme involved accounts with seven broker-dealers: KeyBanc Capital Markets, Inc.(f.k.a. McDonald Investments, Inc.), Dain Rauscher, Inc. (n.k.a. RBC Dain Rauscher, Inc.), Ryan Beck & Co., Inc. (n.k.a. Stifel Nicolaus & Co.), Jesup & Lamont Securities Corp., Jeffries & Company, Inc., Raymond James & Associates, Inc., and Robert W. Baird & Co. Daly also used trading accounts in various company names at National Financial Services, Goldman Sachs Execution & Clearing, LP, Charles Schwab, and Lloyds of London Market Services. 

Daly's scheme was discovered after he was unable to pay for 250,000 shares of stock in Decker Outdoor Corporation which he purchased through McDonald Investments, Inc., causing a loss to McDonald of $1,013,272.56 when it was forced to liquidate the stock.

The Court ordered Daly to pay $5.7 million in restitution. 

Former Brocade CEO Greg Reyes Sentenced to 18 Months; Counsel Blames Lawyers for Failure to Catch Stock Option Backdating

From Law.com, the former Chief Executive Officer of Brocade Communications Systems, Inc., Gregory Reyes was sentenced to 18 months in prison yesterday in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California for securities fraud and backdating stock options. The government had sought a 37 month sentence and a loss amount of $137 million.

Reyes' counsel attempted to argue that his lawyers should have done a better job in advising Reyes. U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer apparently found the argument an interesting one, stating "Yes, it's not a bad question to ask, 'Where were the lawyers?'" However, the Court rejected the argument, finding that Reyes was a sophisticated executive who understood what he was doing.

Reyes was first tried and convicted on the charges in 2006 and was sentenced to 21 months' imprisonment. However, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed his conviction last year based on prosecutorial misconduct in interfering with witness testimony. Reyes was tried a second time in February and March of this year, and was convicted on nine counts. During the trial, Reyes' counsel blamed Brocade's outside counsel, attorneys with the law firm of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Rosati, for failing to catch stock option backdating. However, Reyes' trial counsel never called anyone from the firm to testify. One of the documents at issue in the case was drafted by two experienced attorneys.

The Court received over 400 letters on Reyes' behalf.
 

Government Looks for Success Against Former KB Home Executive Following String of Failures in Stock Option Backdating Cases

After the failure of its backdating case against Gregory Reyes, former Chief Executive Officer of Brocade Communications Systems, prosecutors with the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Central District of California are taking a new tack in its backdating case against former KB Home CEO Bruce Karatz, according to the National Law Journal. Karatz is alleged to have received millions in undisclosed income as a result of backdating stock options, and made $232 million in his last three years as CEO alone. The prosecution has decided to focus on Karatz's personal gain from the alleged scheme, and circumvent the defense--effective in the Brocade Communications Systems case--that backdating is not criminal where the corporation is aware of it, or where a defendant relies on the advice of attorneys or accountants. Defendants have also successfully argued that backdating is a legal and legitimate practice, and that many companies restate their income as a result of such conduct.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed Reyes' conviction in August based on the government's alleged prosecutorial misconduct in intimidating and influencing witnesses. The government's failure in the Reyes case came along with its defeat in 2008 in a backdating case against Kent Roberts, the former General Counsel of McAfee, Inc., a security software firm, and the dismissal of its case against two former executives of Broadcom Corp.

Defendant in Stock Option Backdating Case Requests Hearing Based on Prosecutorial Misconduct/Interference with Witnesses

As reported by Law.com, Bruce Karatz, Chief Executive Officers of KB Home, a home construction corporation based in Los Angeles, California, was indicted in the action of U.S. v. Nicholas, 2:09-cr-00203-ODW (C.D.Ca. 2009), on 20 counts of fraud for defrauding the company and its shareholders of millions of dollars in undisclosed backdated stock option over a period of seven years, and concealing the fraud from KB Home's  directors, compensation committee and shareholders. Karatz's trial in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California is scheduled to begin on February 23.

Karatz's attorneys have requested a hearing regarding whether prosecutorial misconduct has tainted the government's case against Karatz. Karatz contends that two witnesses for the government--James Johnson, former Chairman of the Board of Directors' Compensation Committee for KB Home, and Gary Ray, former Vice President of Human Resources--initially believed that the stock options grant practice was lawful, but changed their position following contacts with the prosecution. Karatz's lawyers want to examine Johnson regarding why he denied allegedly defending KB Home's option granting process during an internal investigation by the company's outside counsel in his statements to prosecutors. 

The defense also wants to question Ray, who has pled guilty to obstruction of justice and is cooperating with the government, regarding why he had allegedly previously maintained that the process was "lawful and proper." Following is a link to

Karatz's Motion for Evidentiary Hearing Regarding Testimony of Crucial Witnesses

.


Karatz's motion is based on an order in December by U.S. District Judge Cormac Carney in the action of U.S. v. Nicholas, SACR 08-00139 CJC (C.D.Ca. 2008), another backdating case, in which the Court dismissed the government's indictment against co-founder of Broadcom Corp., Henry Nicholas, and former Broadcom Chief Financial Officer William Ruehle, blasting the prosecution for "distorting the truth-finding process" by intimidating and improperly influencing key witnesses. Karatz also relies on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' overturning last August of the conviction of former Chief Executive Officer for Brocade Communication Systems, Inc., Gregory Reyes, for backdating based on false statements by the prosecution in closing arguments that Brocade's finance department didn't know about backdating. A hearing on Karatz's motion has been scheduled for February 8.

Hedge Fund Managers, Attorneys, Others Fall in Rajaratnam/Galleon Insider Trading Investigation

Raj Rajaratnam and Danielle Chiesi were indicted in indictment alleging 17 counts of securities and wire fraud on Tuesday in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, U.S. v. Raj Rajaratnam et al, Case No. 09-2306, as reported by the New York Daily News here, here and here, and the New York Times here, here and here. Rajaratnam is a former Bear Stearns hedge fund manager and is the founder of Galleon Management LP, which managed some $3.7 billion in funds. Rajaratnam, a U.S. citizen born in Sri Lanka, was arrested on October 16 at his Manhattan home. U.S. Magistrate Judge Douglas Eaton set Rajaratnam's bail at $100 million which Rajaratnam posted. The indictment alleges a multi-million dollar insider trading scheme that spanned from coast to coast, in which Rajaratnam and Chiesi shared tips on companies like Google, Advanced Micro Devices, Hilton Hotels and others, and reaped more than $20 million in illicit profits by trading on the confidential information. Rajaratnam and Chiesi have both pled not guilty and are fighting the charges. The government claims to have numerous recorded telephone conversations from cooperating witnesses in support of the charges.

Rajaratnam's attorneys also requested a second time that his bail amount be reduced to $20 million. His lawyers disputed the government's reliance on Roomy Khan, an Intel Corp employee and former trader who was convicted of wire fraud in California in 2002 for passing confidential information to Galleon and Rajaratnam when she was an employee of Intel, and who is cooperating with the government. Half a dozen persons, including Ms. Khan, are cooperating in the case.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has also filed civil charges against Rajaratnam. Following Rajaratnam's arrest, investors withdrew more than $4 billion from various Galleon hedge funds, and the firm ceased operations.

The investigation has implicated 21 individuals, including 14 hedge fund managers, lawyers and other investors who were arrested in November. Robert Moffat, a senior official at I.B.M., Rajiv Goel, an executive of Intel; and Anil Kumar, an executive at the consulting firm McKinsey & Company, were arrested at the same time as Rajaratnam, but have not yet been indicted. The Court has granted the prosecution an extension of 30 more days to indict these individuals. The prosecution has described the case as the largest insider trading case in history.

Attorney Brien Santarlas, of the New York law firm of Ropes & Gray, pled guilty to conspiracy to commit securities fraud and wire fraud this week. Santarlas admitted that, from June 2007 to May 2008, he and another attorney, Arthur Cutillo, also with Ropes & Gray, used confidential information regarding acquisitions by 3Com, Inc., and Axcan Pharma, Inc. Bain Capital Partners LLC, a Ropes & Gray client, had announced it planned to acquire 3Com on September 27, 2007, in a deal which would have also involved China's Huawei Technologies Co Ltd. A U.S. government security panel rejected the deal, however. 3Com is now in the process of being purchased by Hewlett-Packard Co. Another Ropes & Gray client, TPG Capital LP, announced on November 29, 2007 that it was acquiring Axcan Pharma.Prosecutors charged Santarlas, Cutillo, Jason Goldfarb and Zvi Goffer with causing trades of 3Com and Axcan stock before the public announcements, making approximately $20 million in profits.Santarlas also faces civil charges by the SEC. His sentencing is tentatively scheduled for June 1. Cutillo was indicted in November.

Rajaratnam has also been linked to Steven Cohen, manager of SAC Capital Advisors, a hedge fund, major art collector, and with a $6 billion net worth, the 36th richest person in America. Cohen's ex-wife, Patricia Cohen, filed a lawsuit in Federal court on Wednesday alleging that Cohen had hid money during their divorce 20 years ago and asserting civil RICO claims. The former Mrs. Cohen alleges that Cohen had made millions from insider trading in the 1980s and had hid the money with the help of one of his real estate partners. Specifically, she claims that Cohen received an insider tip prior to General Electric's purchase of RCA in 1985. She is seeking $300 million from Cohen. SAC issued a statement criticizing the former Mrs. Cohen and her attorney, calling the allegations in the lawsuit "ludicrous" and "without merit."

Federal prosecutors on Wednesday asked for 30 more days to indict four defendants tied to the Galleon Group insider trading scheme, one day after two of the main players were formally indicted on conspiracy and fraud charges.