Header graphic for print
Federal Criminal Defense Blog Federal Criminal Defense and Civil Litigation in Georgia and Beyond

The Government Goes After Wall Street Over the Financial Crisis, Morgan Stanley Now Under Investigation for “Dead President” Deals

Posted in Securities Fraud

 As reported in the Wall Street Journal and virtually everywhere else, Morgan Stanley has joined Goldman Sachs as the latest target of the federal government’s criminal investigation of financial firms relating to the financial crisis which began in 2007, under the government’s theory of criminality of failing to disclose to investors that the firms were "betting" on the failure of certain collateralized debt obligations, or CDOs. According to Federal prosecutors, Morgan Stanley designed CDOs, while at the same time Morgan Stanley’s trading desk allegedly placed bets that their value would decrease. Similar to the government’s investigation of Goldman Sachs, the investigation, headed by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York, is focusing on whether Morgan Stanley made proper representations to investors about its role.

The investigation has focused in particular on two investments created in 2006, named after former U.S. Presidents James Buchanan and Andrew Jackson, known as the "Dead Presidents" deals by traders. Each deal issued approximately $200 million in bonds. Morgan Stanley did not market the deals to customers–the Jackson deal was underwritten and marketed by Citigroup and the Buchanan deal was underwritten and marketed by UBS AG. Citigroup has stated that it is cooperating with the government in the investigation.

However, as in the investigation of Goldman, prosecutors face an uphill climb against numerous obstacles and defenses. Morgan Stanley did make money on its "Dead Presidents" deals, however it lost $9 billion overall on mortgage-backed securities in 2007. Morgan Stanley has informed the media that it did not mislead investors, and that it has examined the "Dead Presidents" transactions and that it does not believe that the investigation has any substance. The allegations are based on documents which Morgan Stanley voluntarily provided to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in response to a subpoena. 

Both the Goldman and Morgan Stanley criminal investigations were the result of a civil fraud investigation of a dozen Wall Street firms begun by the SEC in 2009. Analysts have stated that all Wall Street investment banks have been receiving subpoenas about CDOs and CDO marketing. The SEC has been inquiring with firms regarding whether any of their clients were betting against CDOs.